Saturday, December 3, 2022
HomeWinePortland Commissioner Jo Ann Hardesty and challenger Rene Gonzalez differ, properly, over...

Portland Commissioner Jo Ann Hardesty and challenger Rene Gonzalez differ, properly, over crime, homelessness in 1st fall debate

Throughout their first debate of the autumn runoff, Portland Metropolis Council candidates Jo Ann Hardesty and challenger Rene Gonzalez supplied stark contrasts on crime and homelessness, the problems that voters proceed to say are most urgent.

But every tended to draw back from the divisive barbs and assaults which have typically peppered their public statements and marketing campaign remarks in addition to a few of their supporters’.

The 75-minute back-and-forth was hosted by the Metropolis Membership of Portland and moderated by KGW anchor David Molko. The candidates and moderator appeared collectively in individual and not using a reside viewers.

Gonzalez overtly embraced robust citizen oversight of Portland police and unarmed public security options. However he additionally insisted the town must dramatically improve the variety of cops and crack down on violent and property crimes.

He additionally pitched that Metropolis Corridor ought to contemplate piloting a municipal court docket program to give attention to misdemeanor livability crimes reminiscent of vandalism, automobile and catalytic converter thefts and drug dealing in public areas.

“We’ve spent an excessive amount of time preaching and pandering and never sufficient time defending,” Gonzalez stated.

Hardesty, by comparability, centered on broader public security initiatives she’s launched and shepherded, reminiscent of an effort to scale back shootings in a portion of the Mt. Scott-Arleta neighborhoods via site visitors calming infrastructure and the Portland Road Response, which dispatches a paramedic and social employee to these in disaster outdoors.

“Police are a significant a part of group security however they’re not the one half,” she stated.

Hardesty additionally referred to as for police to crack down on open air drug dealing, together with at Dawson Park, lengthy an necessary web site for Portland’s Black residents and, just lately, the positioning of many deadly shootings.

Each candidates repeatedly expressed deep frustration with Portland’s ongoing incapacity to curb unsanctioned tenting and criticized how cash is spent to handle the humanitarian disaster with out super success.

Hardesty, whose bureau assignments don’t give her direct management over metropolis police or homelessness, stated she needed to see a rise within the variety of small managed camps like the previous Proper 2 Dream Too web site that existed for years in Previous City.

She additionally blasted Mayor Ted Wheeler’s coverage of eradicating unsanctioned encampments, highlighting how most people who find themselves swept from their tents and makeshift dwellings don’t settle for the town’s provide for shelter.

“All we’re doing is pushing folks into neighborhoods as an alternative of giving folks a clear, protected place to remain,” Hardesty stated.

Gonzalez stated more cash wanted to be spent on mass indoor and out of doors shelters as a way to scale back the variety of folks on the streets. Those that refuse accessible shelter or prey upon folks dwelling in unsanctioned camps, he stated, ought to “face the felony justice system.”

A current ballot commissioned by the Portland Enterprise Alliance and different business teams discovered that Gonzalez has a large lead over Hardesty, The Oregonian/OregonLive reported shortly earlier than the controversy started.

The ballot, performed by Portland opinion analysis agency DHM Analysis, discovered 50% of probably voters plan to vote for the challenger, 26% lined up behind the incumbent and 25% nonetheless undecided about six weeks earlier than Election Day.

Through the debate, the candidates every took purpose on the rocky rollout of Measure 110, the brand new state regulation that decriminalized possessions of small quantities of laborious medication, saying that it has fueled habit amongst these dwelling outdoors.

Neither candidate, nonetheless, stated they might advocate for repealing the regulation presently, wanting as an alternative to see if extra folks will start utilizing the promised restoration and therapy companies as soon as they develop into accessible.

Each candidates have been requested to weigh in on November’s poll measure that proposes sweeping adjustments to Portland’s type of authorities and election system.

“At this level, I’m a no,” stated Gonzalez. He acknowledged the will amongst many to vary the town’s type of authorities, however stated he believes too many provisions within the proposal are untested and experimental.

Hardesty refused to reply, saying she believed it was not acceptable for elected leaders to “tip the dimensions somehow,” a veiled criticism of two of her Metropolis Council colleagues, Commissioners Mingus Mapps and Dan Ryan, who’ve spoken out in opposition to it.

About two hours later, whereas talking with an Oregonian/OregonLive reporter, Hardesty stated she deliberate to vote for the measure.

“All people retains asking,” she stated. “So right here it’s: I’m a sure. We want this modification.”

— Shane Dixon Kavanaugh; 503-294-7632

E mail at

Comply with on Twitter @shanedkavanaugh

Our journalism wants your help. Please develop into a subscriber in the present day at


Most Popular

Recent Comments